Evaluation of
Wound Healing Activity of Isolated Compound Quercetin
and Alcoholic Extract of Leaves of Mussaenda
frondosa Linn.
Patil Suhas A.1*, Joshi V.G.2
and Sambrekar S.N.3
1Dept. of
Pharmacognosy, Maratha Mandal’s College of Pharmacy,
Belgaum, India.
2Dept. of
Pharmaceutics. Government College of Pharmacy, Bengaluru,
India
3Dept.
of Pharmacology, Maratha Mandal’s College of
Pharmacy, Belgaum, India.
ABSTRACT:
Since the time immemorial, our traditional
system of medicine and folklore claiming that medicinal plants as a whole or
their parts are being used in all types of diseases. Natural remedies from
medicinal plants are considered to be effective and safe alternative treatment
for wounds. Alcoholic extract of leaves of Mussaenda
frondosa Linn. (Rubiaceae) and its
isolated compound quercetin were evaluated for wound
healing activity by using different types of wound healing models such as
excision wound, incision wound and dead space wound. The results were obtained
in terms of wound contraction, epithelialization time
and tensile strength. All results were significant for different parameters in
wound healing activity in quercetin and alcoholic
extract treated animals compared with control groups. The isolated compound quercetin was confirmed by preliminary phytochemical
investigation, IR, NMR and Mass spectroscopic methods.
KEYWORDS: Mussaenda frondosa Linn, wound healing activity, alcoholic extract, quercetin.
INTRODUCTION:
Wound can be defined as a cut or break in the
continuity of any tissue which may arise due to physical, chemical or microbial
agents1. Wound a clinical
entity contemporary to mankind is a common clinical problem till today. Wound
healing or wound repair is an intricate process in which the skin or some other
organ repairs after injury2. Healing is essentially a survival
mechanism and represents an attempt to maintain normal anatomical structure and
function. All wound heal following a specific sequence of phases which may
overlap3,4. The healing
depends on the type of tissue which has been damaged and the nature of tissue
disruption. The treatment is aimed to shortening the time required for healing
or minimizing the undesirable consequences.
The basic principles of optimal wound healing which
include minimizing tissue damage, maximizing tissue perfusion and oxygenation,
proper nutrition and moist wound healing environment have been recognized for
many years5. A
number of drugs ranging from simple analgesics to complex and expensive
chemotherapeutic agents administered in the management of wound affect healing
either positively or negatively.6
Aspirin, indomethcin, cytotoxic
agents and immunosuppressant have been proved to experimentally to affect
healing negatively.7-10.
Management of wound healing, particularly the under
healing is complicated and expensive programme. Research on wound healing drugs
is a developing area in modern biomedical sciences, Several drugs from plants
have been screened scientifically for evaluation of their wound healing
activity in different pharmacological models and patients, but the potential of
most remains unexplored. Hence there is a dearth of safe, economic and
effective prohealing agents for wound management
programme, which can enhance healing as well as control infection.
Traditionally Mussaenda frondosa Linn commonly called as Nagavalli
reported to possess number of medicinal properties 11,12. Traditionally leaves are used in the treatment of
jaundice, asthma, hyperacidity, fever, ulcers, leprosy, diuretic, wound, 13; antimicrobial14This
plant has been investigated by several workers. Diuretic activity15 Hepatoprotective
activity16, activity on
fever asthama and cough17 was reported in the leaf extract. Hypolipidemic
effect of Methanolic extract of Mussaenda frondosa linn. Leaves in wistar rats was investigated.18
In the Ayurvedic system of medicine, herbal extracts but not
purified compounds have been used from centuries because many constituents with
more than one mechanism of action are considered to be beneficial but no
scientific reports were available for its wound healing activity. Hence the present
study is designed to fill up the lacunae in the literature for wound healing
activity with a view to provide scientific evidence on wound healing.
MATERIALS AND METHODS:
Plant material and preparation
of Extracts:
In the present study, the
leaves of Mussaenda
frondosa
were collected from Jamboti forest Dist. Belgaum,
Karnataka in the month of July. The
plant Mussaenda
frondosa was authenticated from the Scientist Mr.Harsha Hegade of ICMR
(Regional Medical Research centre, Belgaum.) Accession No.RMRC-484. The leaves shade dried powdered and then passed through sieve
No.40 to get uniform powder.
Preparation of alcoholic extract of Mussaenda frondosa Linn:
Around 1 Kg of fresh shade dried powdered leaves was subjected to hot
continuous extraction (soxhlet) with alcohol for 48h
in batches of 250 g each. The extract was filtered, cooled and solvent was
recovered under reduced pressure at 40±5oC by rotary flash
evaporator. The yield was 7.4 g. The extract was stored in a cool place for
further study.
Isolation of
compound:19,20
The dried samples
were separately soxhlet extracted in 80% methanol
(100 ml/gm dry weight) on a water bath for 24 hrs (Subramanian and Nagarajan, 1969). Each of the extracts was concentrated and
reconcentrated in petroleum ether (40°- 60°C)
(fraction-I), ethyl ether (fraction-II) and ethyl acetate (fraction-III) in
succession. Each of the steps was repeated three times to ensure complete
extraction in each case. Fraction I was rejected since it was rich in fatty
substances whereas fraction II was analysed for the
free flavonoids in each of the samples.
Fraction III of
each of the test samples was hydrolysed by refluxing
with 7% H2SO4 (10 ml/gm residue) for 5 hours. The mixture
was filtered and the filtrate extracted with ethyl acetate in a separating
funnel. The ethyl acetate layer was washed with distilled water till neutrality
and dried in vacuo. The residues were taken up
in small volumes of ethanol separately and then subjected to various tests for quercetin.
PHARMACOLOGICAL
ACTIVITY:
Experimental animals:21
Healthy young albino rats of either sex weighing
between 150 to 200 gms (8 to 12 weeks old) were used
for assessing Wound healing and Swiss albino mice of either sex weighing
between 18-22 gms for acute toxicity study to determine
LD50 of various extracts. Animals were procured from Venkateshwara Enterprises, Bangalore. The animals were
randomly selected, marked to permit individual identification, divided into
different groups comprising of six animals in each group and kept in
polypropylene cages for 5 days prior to dosing at 23±10C in 12:12
dark: light cycle with free accession to standard pellet feed (Amrut Sangli) and water ad libitum. This
project was cleared by Institutional Animal Ethical Committee. (Resolution No
0l, dated 2I-12-2009).
Acute Oral Toxicity study:22
The acute oral toxicity study was carried out as per
the guidelines set by Organization for Economic Co–operation and Development
(OECD), received draft guidelines 423, received from Committee for the Purpose
of Control and Supervision of Experiments on Animals (CPCSEA), Ministry of Social Justice and
Empowerment, Government of India. Swiss
albino mice of either sex weighing between 18-22 gms
were fasted over night prior to the acute experimental procedure. The
principle, which is based on a stepwise procedure with the use of a minimum
number of animals per step. The LD50 of different extracts were
determined. The therapeutic dose was calculated as1/10th of the
lethal dose (Table-3) for further investigation.
WOUND HEALING ACTIVITY:
Healthy young albino rats of either sex weighing
between 150 to 200 gms (8 to 12 weeks old) were
selected divided into different groups comprising of six animals in each group.
The animals were depilated at the desired site before wounding. They were
housed individually with free access to food and water, the basal food intake
and body weights to the nearest gram were noted. The animals were starved for
12 h prior to wounding. Under light ether anesthesia wounding was performed semi-asceptically. The first group served as control, second
received alcoholic extract and forth group quercetin
by oral route.
Wound models:
Albino rats of either sex weighing between 150 to 200 gms (8 to 12 weeks old) were used for assessing Wound
healing activity.
Incision wound:23
Under light ether anaesthesia
on the depilated backs of the animal was two paravertebral
straight incisions of 6 cm. were made through entire thickness of the skin, on
either side of the vertebral column with the help of a sharp blade as described
by Ehrlich and Hunt, care was taken to see that the incisions were at least 1
cm apart, using four zero silk thread and straight round bodies needle. Wounds
were then mopped with cotton swabs soaked in 70% alcohol. The animals were caged
individually. Removal of sutures was done on 8th post wounding day.
Tensile strength was determined on 10th post wounding day by
continuous, constant water flow technique of Lee.
Granuloma studies (Dead space wound):24
Physical changes in the granuloma
tissue were studied in this model. Under light ether anaesthesia,
subcutaneous dead space wounds were inflicted in the region of the axilla and groin by making a pouch through a small nick in
the skin. Granuloma formation was induced by
implanting grass pith. Cylindrical grass piths measuring 2.5 cm in length and
0.3 cm, in diameter were introduced in to the pouch similarly. Each animal
received 2 grass piths in different locations. The wounds were sutured and
mopped with an alcoholic swab. Animals were placed in to their individual cages
after recovery from anaesthesia. Excision of the granulomas from the surrounding tissue was performed on the
10th post wounding day under light ether anaesthesia.
Granuloma surrounding the grass piths were excised
and slit open by longitudinal rectangular strips. The tensile strength of a piece measuring
about 15 mm. in length and 8 mm. in width (obtained by trimming the rectangular
strip of granuloma tissue) was determined on 10th
post wounding day by continuous, constant water flow technique of Lee.
The granulation tissue so harvested was subjected to hydroxyproline
estimation. Their weights were expressed as mg/100 gms
body weight as suggested by Gieson and Meli.
Excision wound:
An excision wound was inflicted by cutting away 500mm2
of a pre-determined area on the depilated back of the rat. Epithilization
period was noted as the number of days after wounding required for the scar to
fall off leaving no raw wound behind. Wound contraction rate was monitored by planimetric measurement of the wound on a graph paper
on4th, 8th, 12th and 16th post wounding days and there after daily
until healing was complete. Reduction in wound area was expressed as percentage
of the original wound size on zero days.
Histopathological
studies:
A section of granuloma tissue
was subjected to histopathological examination to
determine the pattern of lay-down for collagen using Van Gieson
and Meli stains.
STATISTICAL ANALYSIS:
All the results were analyzed by ANOVA followed by Dunnett’s test. The level of significance was set at
p<0.05.
RESULTS:
The powdered crude drug was subjected to
determination of extractive value, total ash, water soluble ash, acid insoluble
ash, loss on drying, heavy metals and microorganisms. These values are useful
in determining the quality and purity of crude drug. Further these values
indicate the nature of the constituents present in a crude drug. The results of
physiochemical characterization are presented in Table-1
Since the
alcoholic extract shows higher concentration of flavonoid
it was subjected for the Flavonoid estimation.25
The alcoholic extract showed presence of flavonoid,
190 mgs/g equivalent to Rutin.
Table-1: Physiochemical
characterization of Mussaenda
frondosa
|
Sl. No. |
Parameters |
As per IP/BP Standards |
Results |
|
1 |
Loss on Drying |
NMT 10% w/w |
7.41 |
|
2 |
Total Ash |
- |
10.34 |
|
3 |
Acid insoluble
Ash |
- |
4.13 |
|
4 |
Water soluble Ash |
- |
1.44 |
|
6 |
Total Microbial
count |
NMT 10,000 |
Confirms |
|
7 |
Heavy metals |
|
|
|
|
Mercury |
NMT 10 ppm |
Confirms |
|
Lead |
NMT 10 ppm |
Confirms |
|
|
Lithium |
NMT 10 ppm |
Confirms |
|
|
Cadmium |
NMT 10 ppm |
Confirms |
The phytochemical
tests revealed that the leaves of Mussaenda frondosa Linn possess presence of
various secondary metabolites like steroids, glycosides, saponins,
resins, mucilage and Flavonoid in the alcoholic
extract as shown in table-2
Table-2:
Phytochemical Screening of Mussaenda frondosa Linn.
|
Extracts |
Ster oid |
Flav onoid |
Glyc osides |
Sapo nin |
Resin |
Muci lage |
|
Alcohol |
++ |
+++ |
+ |
++ |
+ |
+ |
+++ =
High
concentration, ++ = medium concentration, + = low concentration, - = absent.
The LD50 was found to be more than 2000
mg/kg of b.w. in acute toxicity testing. The
therapeutic dose was calculated as1/10th of the lethal dose
(Table-3) for further investigation. The results of oral toxicity studies of
various extracts is shown in table-3
Table-3:
Results of Acute Toxicity studies
|
Sl. No. |
Extracts/ Isolated compound |
LD50(mg /kgb.w.) |
ED50 (mg/ kg b.w.) |
|
1 |
Alcohol |
2000 |
200 |
|
2 |
Quercetin |
300 |
30 |
Table-4: Influence of
different extracts on Excision wound model
|
Group |
Mean ± SEM of %
of wound closure on |
Epithilization Time (Days) |
Scar Area (mm2) |
|||
|
4th day |
8th day |
12th day |
16th day |
|||
|
Control |
12.20± 1.00 |
22.87± 1.29 |
36.20± 1.66 |
63.95± 3.34 |
25.52± 1.49 |
5.22± 1.41 |
|
Quercetin |
21.13± 1.00*** |
39.53± 2.90*** |
66.22± 2.13*** |
93.32± 1.95*** |
12.70± 0.34*** |
6.80± 0.38*** |
|
Alcoholic extract |
20.20 ± 1.05*** |
37.93± 2.81*** |
62.95± 3.15*** |
90.43± 2.11*** |
13.88± 0.36*** |
7.83± 0.52*** |
Note:
Data analysed by ANOVA followed by Dunnett’s test. ***= p < 0.001
The isolated compound showed positive tests for flavonoid (Ayurvedic
pharmacopoeia of India 1990) and for quercetin (Indian
Herbal Pharmacopoeia 2002). IR, Mass and NMR spectral analysis confirmed the
chemical structure of the compound.
1H NMR spectrum (400 MHz, DMSO-d6),
δ, ppm (J, Hz): 6.17 (1H, s, Phenyl-C7
proton); 6.39 (1H, s, Phenyl-C9 proton); 6.88 (1H, m, Phenyl-C15
proton); 7.54 (1H, m, Phenyl-C16 proton); 7.66 (1H, s, Phenyl-C12
proton); 9.36 (3H, b, of-OH
proton); 10.72 (1H, b, of-OH proton); 12.48 (1H, s, of-OH proton); MS spectrum, m/z: 303
[M+1]+.
2-(3,4-dihydroxyphenyl)-3,5,7-trihydroxy-4H-chromen-4-one
The results of the excision wound model are given in
table-4.In an excision significant wound healing activity was observed in both
the groups of animals treated with alcoholic extract and quercetin
respectively. The percentage of wound closure was significant p<0.001)in the
animals treated with quercetin 66.22 ± 2.13 on day 12th
and 93.32 ± 1.95 on day 16th
respectively. While in control animals it was only36.20 ± 1.66 and 63.95 ± 3.34
respectively. The time required for complete epithelization
of excision wound is an important parameter to assess the wound healing
process. It was found that mean time taken for complete epithelization
was less in quercetin treated group than animal
treated with alcoholic extract. The quercetin and
alcoholic extract treated groups showed a scar area of 06.80 ± 0.38 and 7.83 ± 0.52mm2 respectively
compared to scar area of control 15.22 ± 1.41 mm2.
The results of incision wound model are given in
table-5.In an incision wound study, the quercetin and
alcoholic extract treated groups showed significant breaking strength (378.30 ±
2.20 and 372. 25 ± 2.29 respectively)
compared to control (335.20 ± 2.05).
The results of dead space wound model are given in
table-6.The tensile strengths of granuloma tissue
were determined by the water flow technique of Lee. The quercetin
and alcoholic extract treated group showed highly significant increase in
tensile strength (500.30±3.19 and 475.30±2.73 resp.) compared to control
(424.40 ± 2.30).The quercetin and alcoholic extract
treated groups also showed significant increase in the dry weight of granuloma tissue (42.57 ± 1.63 and 41.48 ± 1.60
respectively) compared to control (32.23 ± 1.57). The The
quercetin and alcoholic extract also showed
significant increase in the hydroxyproline content (10.20
± 0.47 and 9.93± 0.44 resp.) as compared to control (7.35 ± 0.11).
Histopathological studies of granulation tissue of alcoholic
extract treated animals showed significant increase in the collagen deposition
with macrophages, tissue edema and more fibroblasts compared to control. (Fig.1,
2 and 3).
Control
Quercetin
Alcoholic
Extract
Table-5: Influence of
different extracts on Incision wound model
|
Group |
Dose (oral) mg/kg b.w. |
Wound breaking strength(g) |
|
Control |
1% CMC |
335.2 ± 2.05 |
|
Quercetin |
30 |
378.3 ±2.20*** |
|
Alcoholic extract |
200 |
372.25 ±
2.29*** |
Note: Data analysed by ANOVA
followed by Dunnett’s test. ***= p < 0.001
Table-6: Influence of
different extracts on Dead space wound model
|
Group |
Dose (oral) mg/kg b.w. |
Wound breaking strength(g) |
Granuloma
tissue dry weight (mg) |
Hydroxyproline |
|
Control |
1% CMC |
424.40 ± 2.30 |
32.23 ± 1.57 |
7.35 ± 0.11 |
|
Quercetin |
30 |
500.30± 3.19*** |
42.57 ± 1.63*** |
10.20 ± 0.47*** |
|
Alcoholic extract |
200 |
475.30± 2.73*** |
41.48 ± 1.60*** |
9.93 ± 0.44*** |
Note: Data analysed by ANOVA
followed by Dunnett’s test. ***= p < 0.001
DISCUSSION:
In the present ionvestigation
quercetin was isolated from the alcoholic extract of
the leaves of Mussaenda
frondosa. The crude alcoholic extract and the
isolated compound quercetin were concomitantly tested
for wound healing activity.
Granulation, collagen, maturation and scar formation
are some of the phases of wound healing The various wound healing models have
been chosen in our study because use of single model is inadequate and no
reference standard exist that can collectively represent the various phases of
wound healing. The wound breaking strength is determined by the rate of
collagen synthesis so by the maturation process where there is covalent binding
of collagen fibers through inter and intra molecular cross linking. The
significant increase in breaking strength, hydroxyproline
concentration and dry weight of granulation tissue by this we can assume that quercetin and alcoholic extract of Mussaenda frondosa have increased collagen and
have altered the maturation process by affecting cross linking of collagen or
quality of collagen fibrils. Increase in dry granulation tissue weight
indicates presence of higher protein content.
The measurement of hydroxyproline
could be used as an index for collagen turnover. In present study there is
significant increase in hydroxyproline content the
animals treated with quercetin and alcoholic extract
indicating rapid collagen turnover.
The alcoholic extract of Mussaenda frondosa revealed presence of
secondary metabolites like steroids, glycosides, saponins, resins, mucilage and flavonoids.
Flavonoids are known to reduce lipid peroxidation not only by preventing or slowing cell
necrosis but also by improving vascularity. Hence any
drug that inhibits lipid peroxidation is believed to
increase the viability of collagen fibrils by increasing the circulation,
strength of collagen fibres, preventing the cell
damage and by promoting the DNA synthesis.26
Flavonoids27
are also known to promote the wound healing process mainly due to their
antimicrobial property which is responsible for wound contraction and increased
rate of epithelialisation.
Between the three tested groups the wound healing
activity of the constituent quercetin was
comparatively more. In the alcoholic extract the lesser activity may be due to
the presence of other chemical constituents that hindered the activity of quercetin
CONCLUSION:
The use of leaves of Mussaenda frondosa in folk medicine for the
treatment of wounds has been justified by this work, as it showed remarkable
wound healing property. These findings clearly justifies for the inclusion of
leaves of Mussaenda
frondosa in
the management of wound healing. The wound healing activity of this plant may
be due to presence of flavonoid quercetin.
To conclude the quercetin and
alcoholic extract of Mussaenda
frondosa
Linn. exibited significant wound healing activity in
excision, incision and dead space wound model. Hence the present findings
provide scientific evidence that Mussaenda frondosa Linn as potent wound healer.
REFERENCES:
1.
Schilling J.A., Wound Healing. Phys. Rev. 1968;
48:375-423.
2.
Stadelmann WK,Digenis AG & Tobin GR.Physiology
& healing dynamics of chronic cutaneous wounds.The American J.of Surgery,1998;176(2:26S-38S.
3.
Midwood KS,William LV & Schwarzbaur JE.Tissue Biochemistry. and cell Bio.l2004; 36(6):1031-37.
4.
Mercandetti M & Cohen AJ,
Wound healingL:Healing and repair,2005;
e-medicine.com
5.
Pierce GF and Mustoe TA.
Pharmacologic enhancement of wound healing Annu.Rev.
.Med. 1995; 46:467-81.
6.
Prasad D,Rao CM.Wound healing profile of keterolac
metronidazole and tinidazole
administerd postsurgially.Ind.J.Exp.
Biol.1995; 33:845-47.
7.
Lee KH.Studies on the
mechanism of action of salisylates III. Effect of
vitamin A on the wound healing retardation action of aspirin.J.Pharma.Sci.1968;
57:1238-40.
8.
Rao CM,Ramesh KV,BairyKL,Kulkarni
DR.A simple method of quantity maturation of wound collagen. Ind.J.Exp.Biol.1991; 29:156-58.
9.
Raju S, Kulkarni DR.Vitamin A reverses
the wound healing suppressant effect of cyclophosphamide.Ind
J. Pharmacol.1986;18:154-57.
10.
Holla RK,Sequeira RP, Kulkarni DR.Cyclisporin & wound; healing Ind.J.Exp.
Biol.1988:26:869-73.
11.
http://www.springerlink.com/content/m627322 p 542
97782/
12.
Wealth of India A Dictionary of Raw material and
Industrial products Vol.
13.
Basu, B.D., Kirtikar. K. Indian Medicinal Plants. Vol.II
New Delhi M/S Bishen Singh, Mahendra
Palsingh.1481.
14.
Dr.Jain S.K. 1991,
Dictionary of Indian folk medicine and Ethnobotany,
Deep publication. 83.
15.
Roshishaliya AP,Kumar Upendra,Upwar N,Patel N.Diuretic study of ethanolic and aqueous extract of Mussaenda frondosa Linn.in normal rats.
http://www.scientificipca.org
16.
Sambrekar SN,Patil PA,Kangralkar VA
Protective activity of Mussaenda
frondosa
leaf extract against paracetamol
induced hepatic damage in
wistar rats. .J. of pharmacology
research, 2010, vol.3No.4;
17.
Mussaenda frondosa leaf
extract against fever asthama and cough.J.Ethnobiology
& Ethnomedicine, 2008; 4:22.
18.
John Wesley et.al.Hypolipidimic
effect of methanolic extract of Mussaenda frondosa linn.
Leaves in high fat diet fed rats.J. of Pharmacol.Research,2009,vol.2,issue
4:579-81.
19.
Mahesh Chand
Meena and Vidya Patni., Isolation and Identification of Flavonoid
"Quercetin" from Citrullus
colocynthis (Linn.) Schrad. Asian J. Exp. Sci., Vol. 22, No. 1, 2008; 137-142.
20.
A.A. H,Amadu,H.S.Hasan,M.U.Abubakarb
and I. N. Akpulu., Flavonoid
glycosides from Byrsocarpus coccineus leaves. Schum and Thonn(Connaraceae) African Journal of Traditional,
Complimentary and Alternative Medicines, Vol.4, No. 3, 2007, pg. 257-260
21.
Ghosh MN Fundamentals of Experimental Pharmacology. 2005:1-6.
22.
OECD/ OCDE Guidelines for the testing of
chemicals, Revised Draft Guidelines 423; Acute oral toxicity - Acute toxic
class method, Revised document; October 2000.
23.
Warner S,Breededen
M,Hubner G,Greenhalgh DG
& Longaker MT.Introduction
of keratinocyte growth factor expression is reduced
and delayed during wound healing in the genetically diabetic mouse.J.Investing Dermatol.1994;103:469.
24.
Dispasaqulae G,Meli A.effect of body weight
changes on the formation of cotton pellet induced
granuloma.J.Pharmacol.1965;17:379-82.
25.
Helmja K., Vaher M., Gorbatšova J. and Kaljurand M. (2007). Characterization
of bioactive compounds contained in vegetables of the Solanaceae
family by capillary electrophoresis.
Proc. Estonian Acad. Sci. Chem., 56;
(4) 172–186.
26.
Getie M,Gebre M,Reitz R,Neubert RH.Evaluation of the
release profiles of flavonoids from
topical formulations of the crude extracts of the leaves of Dodonea
viscose Pharmazie.2002; 57:320-22.
27.
Tsuchiya H,et.al.
Comparative study on antibacterial activity of phytochemical 7-34. flavones
against methicillin resistant staphylococcus aureus.J.Ethnopharmacol.1996;
50:2
Received on 10.08.2011
Accepted on 30.09.2011
© A&V Publication all right reserved
Research Journal of Pharmacognosy and
Phytochemistry. 3(6): Nov. - Dec. 2011, 266-271